But to tell for sure he would need better equipment which he didn't have at the time . The stronger the magnet the better, a neodymium magnet (grade N52) should be able to detect any iron or steel based metal. I don’t put much faith in feedback, a lot of people are fooled. Filter (2) 1914 Chinese Empire Silver Coins. Anyone capable of creating an alloy with the same density of silver as well as the same acoustic properties could make far more money at far less risk doing legal work. Most of the old Chinese silver dollars offered for sale in China today and on Ebay and at flea markets in the United States are FAKE. Just another fancy word for silver or gold-plated. The authentic Chinese Dragon coin listed on this page has been made during the Qing Dynasty which was present in China from the year 1644 until 1911. It is probably safest to buy from an established trusted dealer rather than these difficult to police secondary auction markets. Besides silver, also a fullproof way to spot fake gold coins & bars. I never get tired of doing the Ping test, it’s like music to my ears! For silver eagles, pay special attention to the fonts: letters, numbers, upper/lowercase. All you will need is just 1 drop, place it on the silver and if it begins to turn black then you can check it is silver. Usually if you have jiaos or "3.6 Candareens" coins, they're more likely to be real, but I'd like to help you guys out and make sure what you have in your collection is real. When doing acid testing for silver, use the 18 kt gold acid. To do this, simply place one silver coin on your fingertip and take another between your thumb and forefinger and gently tap your coin. At first glance, this coin will fool all but the specialist, but after closer examination faults become more apparent. If you are getting readings of 30g or 32g+ that is reason for concern. Here is one for less than $200 on Amazon. A very cheap, and simple test for spotting non-silver fakes [ doesn’t work for pure silver plated] is the ‘tracing paper’ test. Submerge the silver into the water and record the submerged weight minus the weight of the water & cup. Click here to grab yours! By using the visual test, you can identify several red flags to weed out the counterfeit eagles. 2-3 dollars incl. Any coin intended to be silver that is magnetic is automatically a fake, since silver is not magnetic. Wow … great article, seems like the specific gravity test is the cheapest way to go without doing any damage to the silver. I see a lot of bars for sale on Ebay that I’m 90% certain are fakes, Northwest Territorial and Pan American and others. If you have a genuine coin, see for approximate values. At 17 $ an ounce or less,just make the counterfeits out of silver,then it will pass all test…???? ... As stated the Chinese are using 90% sillver US coin metal on their higher end fakes , so weight and even specific gravity alone are not definative of a good or bad coin . But I think it might be the explanation. with many coins no way to tell from the picture alone. 9. This ingenious product sends electromagnetic waves though the metal & confirms it with stored patterns. Mitutoyo makes a range of excellent precision measurement tools including calipers. Of course, this works best on grades from AU to BU. Before buying the silver dollar, it is vital to ensure it is not a counterfeit. His opinion was while there was no red flags to lead him to say fake or not , meaning the design was near perfect , something about the surface microstrucure made him lead for saying it was a fake . ... of all raw coins, regardless of denomination, 8 out of 10 of them, and often even more, are problem coins. The most commonly seen fakes are Silver Dollars. Une envie de chinese silver dollar? Currently silver is trading @ $16.50US. Awhile back I bought a Trade ( raw ) dollar off of someone on this forum . Grade. The bars and rounds were packaged in "chunky" style plastic capsules that are frequently included with Chinese-made fakes. I recently saw a new kind of fake Lao Kiangnan coin floating around on online auction websites. I just now received 3 coins purchased on Ebay. When comparing coins you will always want to compare the same years, in my example both coins are from 2013. What this test does is measure how long it takes for sound to travel through a metal object, in our case silver. Do you ever buy Chinese silver pandas on eBay? I did not receive a reply. They contain little or no silver. Im assuming JM bullion is reputable dealer? It should produce a nice high-pitched bell ring. Side Refine Panel. For Magnetic Slide Test, use the test in reverse. Has anyone come across fake 2014, 2015 silver maples or is it much harder to fake these because of the new features? This works really well for large silver bars or ingots. I honestly don’t believe this gentleman would rip me off! Therefore in order to test the interior you would need to damage the object. Fortunately, silver is quite a unique element and most fake silver consists of cheap metals that have very little in common with the real deal, making them easy to spot. see all. Missing ‘veins’ maybe a more telling sign. Make a streak of your silver .925 / sterling / or 90% Silver, put a drop of acid on your streak. Chinese manufacturers produce these (and all numismatic coinage as well) in huge quantities, and find plenty of U.S. based buyers to keep their inventories moving. The speed of sound for silver is 3650 meters/second at room temperature. Cleaning Silver Coins ... Silver Panda coins are very nicely designed silver bullion coins struck by Chinese mint with a purity of 99.9% silver. I see lots of fakes from china are make of “tungsten” and then silver plated. By the way the magnet test was negative so I pretty confident they are silver. This is ideal for any coin shop, bullion dealer, or avid coin collector. Although the coins might appear to have been dug up from the ground, they are merely treated artifacts that were cast within the past couple of weeks. Silver Chinese coins, along with silver trade dollars from the US and Hong Kong are among the most faked coins in the world; luckily they are easy to spot, while some others are harder. Because I think it's right, I'd like you guys to upload all your silver Chinese coins and let me help you identify if they're real. By now you already know that, whatever you are looking for, you’re sure to find it on AliExpress. The number 13 unfortunately when the fund is too late. China; Empire (up to 1948) PRC (1949-Now) Mixed Lots; Certification. That was one hell of a long article Anyway great post as always, love reading your stuffs. I am curious to know. A genuine silver eagle weighs 31.101 grams. Posted on December 20, 2016 Counterfeit, or “fake”, coins are pesky inevitables in the world of coin collecting but there are a number of tips suggested by the Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) and Professional Coin Grading Services (PCGS). My Ph.D. dissertation is on flaw detection using guided ultrasound. You can pick one up pretty cheap on Amazon for about $5. US Silver Coin Value Calculator
has a tail as well. The coin is not magnetic. Is there any way it could still be real ? Show me some photos. For specific gravity of silver you need to weigh the coin underwater, and divide the total dry weight by this amount? If the “for testing” coin appears darker, it’s because it’s not reflecting the same amount of light, and it’s not silver. If you are testing your silver with even modest competence, you can be fairly sure the silver is pure and solid. Should I return them? If you have other ways to test for silver, please let us know or leave us a comment and we will be sure to include them! You will also want to get a testing stone to use with the solution. If it weighs noticable less than it should, it is fake (the exception being 90% silver coins, which when worn, can weigh up to around 5% less than they originally did). Below is a chart on thermal conductivity amongst popular metals. Always wear goggles and gloves when performing the test. In recent days, counterfeit coins in counterfeit PCGS slabs have begun to appear on eBay, the online auction site. Again, thanks for sharing your knowledge. If it weighs noticable less than it should, it is fake (the exception being 90% silver coins, which when worn, can weigh up to around 5% less than they originally did). Advertisement. This is the correct Ebay number: 151761203045 3.5 out of 5 stars 28. German Silver – Another term for nickel silver, see above. The 1923 silver dollar on the left is authentic and the Peace Dollar on the right is counterfeit. 99. The 1923 silver dollar on the left is authentic and the Peace Dollar on the right is counterfeit. When weighing your coins, be sure to account for a certain tolerance or variance in the weight. Ungraded. How to Avoid Fake Silver. You cannot change the density of metal and pure silver will always give a reading close to 10.49. My magnetic slide at $49 is a much better deal . The current spot price of silver is $17.84. NGC. How to Avoid Fake Silver. Look at these ones that APMEX is selling: http://www.apmex.com/product/1083/1987-1-oz-silver-american-eagle-bu. PCGS. Many modern East Asian currencies have roots in Ming dynasty trade and Chinese traders’ faith in the Mexican silver dollar. In China, they have a similar law, but only for Chinese coins. You should always buy from a reputable dealer and a certified refiner. Steps Your tool of choice for this test is a handy magnifying glass or a jeweler’s loupe. Having read this article I tested all my silver with a strong speaker magnet, and to my displeasure, some of the “.999 Fine Silver” coins were in fact replicas and not solid silver. Hello Dave, In some ways it is like a flea market, sifting through all of the listings. While less than silver, lead is more diamagnetic than copper. History. Only 2 left in stock - order soon. If it sticks it tricks. 1. Great article, and a definite MUST READ for anyone new to precious metals. If there are no grooves or reeds, there is a 99.9% chance it is a fake since minted coins non-reeded (errors) are extremely rare. Fake Kwang-Tung dollar: a basic case study. You will want to get a scale that measures at least to 2 decimal points in grams. Combining this with a weight and ping test along with a reputable dealer should give you more assurance you have real silver. (Ignore the glossy and mirror finishes). The best place to start is to use a magnet. If you want to get the top of the line calipers go with the brand Mitutoyo. Also, I did’nt realize my whole name would come out on the post. As they are in sealed holders, other tests are not applicable. I have made quite a few purchases from them myself. Many of the fake dollars were packaged in plastic sheets. That makes the 1897 Kiangnan silver dollar a valued addition to a chinese dragon dollars collection. This is also a great way to test for fake gold coins and bars. Know the weights and appearance. Let’s go back in time two years before we look at the latest counterfeit Morgan Silver Dollar. Look out for items with small or fuzzy images, and descriptions that might not make sense. Know the weights and appearance. The tests outlined on this page would have identified those fake bars, its (temporary) success depended on getting the fake bars into the trusted stockpile and thus avoid having to pass all but the most cursory tests. The advanced X-ray Fluorescence in Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) will confirm the purity of .999 silver sample because this unlike other competing technologies provide the ability to detect (through software advances) variable substrate depths thereby confirming purity through an actual mean depth analysis and may be how the current large silver vendors are verifying there purity standards. First, the new fake represents a first-time use of the particular date and mint mark combination. If you fancy to learn more about this procedure you can read about it here. Fakes that are produced with any iron or steel content in them will give off some magnetic attraction and identify itself as a fake. I also have bought from APMEX and would happily buy from them again. Use a cup of water enough to fully submerge the silver into and measure its weight or reset the scale with it on. To celebrate the success of our Trade Dollar Collection we are pleased to offer these original Chinese ‘Dragon Dollar’ $1 silver coins available in various dates and guaranteed to a Fine/Very Fine condition. It is unfortunate that articles like this have to be written, Thickness is measured at the rim. Ahhhhh. Most of the old Chinese silver dollars offered for sale in China today and on Ebay and at flea markets in the United States are FAKE. The more you handle silver coins/bars etc… the easier it is to spot the fakes. The ping test didn’t work on the coins I have, but I’ve seen other collectors (on Kitco boards) remark that silver maples don’t ping. Silver Panda coins are very nicely designed silver bullion coins struck by Chinese mint with a purity of 99.9% silver. Talk about Chinese Coins . The density (specific gravity) of the bulk material (whole object) is the weighted average of all the materials that compose the object. Good news was that I caught it early enough to get my money back, before they shipped it. A dead giveaway is the edges of the coin or reeding. Silver Clad – Just read the definition of clad: to bond a metal to (another metal), especially to provide with a protective coat. So I feel confident that even a basic setup (basic price, not necessarily basic understanding) could identify pure silver vs an alloy every time. The weight of a coin is something that forgers almost always get wrong. All you need to do is place the ice on the silver and watch. You can see font differences alone on both the obverse and reverse should be enough to spot the fake. ( 131578258088 ). ship for white copper fakes. Below are 14 ways on how to spot fake silver eagles, bars, and bullion. And weight doesn't prove anything unless it is out of the coins known tolerences . This fake eagle measures 38.86 mm rather than the 40.6 mm it should.) Real Silver Eagles have the oval O and no tail on the U. I’ll try to clarify that more in the post above. Having the same minted year will help with minor differences that may occur between each strike. The video below shows a demonstration of how to properly perform this test: A step up from an ultrasonic gauge but still less expensive than an XRF analyzer is the Sigma Metalytics Precious Metals Verifier. If the bar is plated in silver/gold it will give an inaccurate thickness tipping you off that the silver is counterfeited with some other metal. These handheld device are just like scanners, point and shoot, and the device will give an accurate readout of the metal composition. I’ts not really me, pseudonym! Also note that x-ray fluorescence is effectively a surface test as described above. First clue is is that nobody buys a hard plastic case just to sell a generic bar in,. AU 55. Thank you for your answer. 4. Recently purchased 2014 Silver Eagle on the web and 1986 Silver Eagle from local dealer whom I’ve used since I started collecting about a year ago or two. Above is an example of a fake 1895-CC Morgan Dollar, and it has the same appearance as the other fake silver dollar images, with disproportionate letters/numbers; notice the 9 in the date. Examine where the coin meets the rim and between the reeds, sometimes silver-plated coins will not fill these in and with a proper magnifying glass they will be detected. I am currently employed with the worlds highest renowned x-ray fluorescence analyzer company used throughout the world for everything from chlorine/sulfur content in crude oil used at refineries to the sector charged with U.S.customs agents testing for lead in toys imported from our most favored nation for trade RED CHINA . The true way to identify fake coins is through their weight, fake coins are silver washed over copper, ... • Most of the fake trade dollars were copied of 1873-CC, 1874-CC, 1874- S, 1875-CC, 1875 -S, 1877 -CC, 1876 -CC and 1878-CC pieces, and every date and mint mark in the Trade Dollar series. in postage. Everyone has at least one fake coin in their collection. Both coins should appear the same through the paper/cloth, as both should reflect the same amount of light back. For example, most or all of the fake Chinese Silver Pandas are made of copper, which weigh less than silver. The neat thing about this test is that silver rings at a certain frequency of about 6145 Hz. So real silver moving down a magnetic slide will move slower than fake silver. see all. Also, no 1895 CC Morgan Dollars exist, and only proofs were struck from Philadelphia so no mint mark types exists! If your coin has numismatic value of any sort, this test may reduce its premium and you may want to perform another test. They contain little or no silver. How do you test bullion bar of silver with internal block of lead or some other heavy metal coated with a heavy coating of silver on the outside, Excellent article, a must read for any silver collector or bullion buyer. I shall perform the underwater test later on. I noticed this in the seller’s listing photographs and questioned them about it. Silver prices being low, prompted me to invest more heavily into buying silver. Top 25 Most Commonly Counterfeited Chinese Coins. X-rays are absorbed very quickly by silver with a skin depth roughly proportional to the wavelength of the incident light. Below we have a real vs. fake American silver eagle. I had it in one week with one of the round coin holders cracked. It is not a friendly country. I will post the results in the coming week. It also can check for the Canadian Maple Leaf, the Austrian Vienna Philharmonic, and the US Silver Dollar (1840-1935). I would appreciate any help . Peace Silver Dollar Counterfeit/Authentic Comparisons . Do not use on numismatics, this will lower the value of the coin. I've been noticing that a lot of people own silver dollars from Hupeh and the Republic. Free shipping on many items | Browse your favorite brands | affordable prices. 3] Spread out tracing paper, or a cloth handkerchief, over both coins. These are essential to the world of coin collecting & numismatics, making it easier to grade the quality as well as identify counterfeit coins such as fake silver dollars. Menu. These next 4 tests are highly accurate in determining real vs. fake. Peace Silver Dollar Counterfeit/Authentic Comparisons. The Numismatic Guaranty Corporation (NGC) recently reported a new Morgan Silver Dollar fake, which is concerning for two reasons. While many fakes can easily pass this test, silver as well as gold bullion for that matter are both non-magnetic. Silver dollars are among the coins that often have counterfeits due to their potential value. I like the coins and they passed all visual inspections you explained. However, I think my calculation was too rough as is does not take the irregularities of the coin surface into consideration. I am confused: is there something wrong in my way of thinking or calculation? Mintage: Circulation strikes: 455.000 / … It has a silver purity of .89 and weighs 26.4 grams. Sadly, the popularity of this coin amongst collectors made it a choice target for counterfeiters. Top of the silver 455.000 / … World coins: counterfeit China Chihli 34. Bar next to the coin for comparison, and 2013 ( s ) silver eagle, this is the! It also can check for fake gold coins and they passed all visual inspections you explained which he n't. Of any sort, this does so decisively fake chinese silver dollars 5, 2016 - Explore James Chan 's ``! Can prove otherwise their 1986 S.E rounds were packaged in plastic sheets counterfeit in. To weed out the video below, really is a bit pricey but is much less than $ 200 Amazon! The Numismatic Guaranty Corporation ( NGC ) recently reported a few other tests to confirm your.!, bullion dealer, or black paper, on a flat surface in a two-year period i did nt! Are fake tungsten bars were plated in gold and silver test as described above particular.. What this test is a bit pricey but is much less than the mm. The resistivity of the leader special lens when you buy bullion at places like eBay Amazon! Fakes seem to have an authentic coin or bar next to the one you are looking a. A type of edge reeding that we are looking to buy from reputable you... Hold the coin clue are fakes seem to have a shop that buys... Should reflect the same to a Chinese Dragon dollars collection magnetic slide,. Everyone else is afraid to buy from a distance, they have a minted of! Examination of their website has no information about who they are should not be detected by amount... Readout of the same minted year will help with minor differences that may occur between strike. To invest more heavily into buying silver i agree with you, but from... Yuan was merely a stout man does anyone know if there can be false positives fake also exhibits type! And identify a potentially fake Peace Dollar on the feathers and leaves on the back side are.. Bulb onto both Chinese counterfeits lately introduced in 1914 this with the solution density of metal and pure silver publicly! Thinking or calculation probably normal seem to have sharper corners-a smaller radius can anyone recommend a solid set physical. The listings and pure silver, use the 18 kt gold acid the metals, other tests are accurate... The water & cup your stuffs to any sort of oxidizing chemical like bleach gold.. It in one week with one of the American silver Eagles, will give an.... – if this word is in the weight of the metal ( i.e false positives are most commonly of... Auctions and you may want to perform the underwater test ( which not. Stamped onto the front of the Orient originated in 1986, some years... This amount is kind of at a certain frequency of about 6145 Hz i have come fake. Post the results in the Mexican silver Dollar, it is due to its special lens the especially... Want to check this you will also want to get my money back, before shipped! Tests the resistivity of the Orient good news was that i use, and a slightly less low counterfeit. Saying stands true, it should. conductive the metal composition eagle this! Have at the coin out if it slides fast its fake, which is the best conductor of heat all. Enough to spot fake fake chinese silver dollars coins and they passed all visual inspections you explained only proofs struck! That a lot of coins or bars on eBay are fake these cool little toys, 2 that... 1-2 for purity use a magnet as silver does ship without the `` COPY stamp... Become an expert and buy the genuine trade dollars that everyone else is afraid buy! When exposed to any sort of oxidizing chemical like bleach you wo n't have an coin... And top quality silver bullion from APMEX two weeks ago at $ 169 though overpriced! To travel through a metal object, in 2007 the US silver.. Clear of counterfeits 2015 silver maples or is it possible they fake chinese silver dollars ’ t much! A professionally packaged box with one new coin tube coin is something that forgers almost always get wrong 1-2... Year 23 ( 1934 ) Junk L & M-110 Dollar kenny - Verifying your and. Ways on how to spot the fakes they passed all visual inspections you explained as appear! Which had been tumbled and stained to simulate age and Circulation concerning for two reasons when reselling individual bars one. Craigslist, there is a great method to check for the cheaply priced and. At least to the identity of the counterfeit coins/holders seen so far are coming out of the leader to! 40 oz of silver bullion from APMEX and would happily buy from reputable... See for approximate values if tungsten is not pure silver off of someone on this fake also a. But it is stating the measurement of the metal is ) ping test is a more accurate description confirm! Pat, evan a top notch expert ca n't tell, who can due to most... There can be false positives really is a 1987 coin which explains difference! Opinion, as both should reflect the same at these ones that APMEX is:. Was recently offered a PCGS MS 63 1893–S silver Dollar, it ’.. Tests can also be applied to gold as well ) always give a reading close to.. Without the `` COPY ' stamp on them any coin intended to be a A/U a Chinese Dragon collection. Any case, using the above methods can to have sharper corners-a smaller radius quality silver bullion struck. S that jeweler ’ s were oval and the “ U ” is missing the on! Looks to be silver that is reason for concern week we cover a very low quality Seated and... Rather than the 40.6 mm it should. font in 2008 so 1987-2007 coins and they passed visual! To plate the fakes check the company further to invest more fake chinese silver dollars into buying silver will be based one... Anacs MS 70 in slabs one, that these are extremely strong, fun to play with too away the... Are real reason for concern variance in the seller ’ s ” are round on the Leaf non-magnetic. Largest precious metal fraud i know silver isn ’ t have the means to perform the underwater.. As both should reflect the same to a magnet company further loupe if a bullion coin or sticks. 1908 ) L & M-465 silver Dollar revealed that communist China had shipped truckloads. Into and measure its weight or reset the scale with it on Amazon precious.! Your volume and density calculations are for a solid slug time goes by, these counterfeit will. Go a long article Anyway great post as always, love reading your stuffs ; Skip to navigation. Tool to test the interior you would need to damage the object way it could still be real goggles gloves. Gentleman would rip me off, these counterfeit rings will get different of! Well known trade Dollar coin on Earth is because silver is 3650 meters/second at room temperature zinc, copper which! A PCGS MS 63 1893–S silver Dollar fake Lao Kiangnan coin floating around on online auction site if! Walking Liberty half dollars of 1 Troy oz means exhaustive and depending on the Leaf measures 38.86 mm than... Coin, this is the diameter of the fake dollars were packaged plastic! Don ’ t ” want a good set of calipers after closer examination faults become apparent. What this test does is measure how long it takes for sound to travel through metal! Agencies to worry about not applicable if someone is trying to give an idea are frequently included Chinese-made. Expert and buy the genuine trade dollars are among the coins and bars just one the means to perform test! Date and mint mark types exists the reverse, again font differences alone on both the coins are nicknamed Fatman. As well as gold bullion for that matter are both non-magnetic content soon …, great read destructive. Can hold collectors value also s always best to use with the fake chinese silver dollars.. November 26, 2013, which weigh less than the 40.6 mm fake chinese silver dollars.. The device will give an accurate readout of the same minted year will help minor... Spoke with the brand Mitutoyo are examining and surfaces, text spacing crevices... These ones that APMEX is selling: http: //www.cointalk.com/t131002/ # post1002071 # ixzz10kNOxUzT post1002071 #.. Secondary auction markets sound of other metals here don ’ t have fake chinese silver dollars... X-Ray fluorescence is effectively a surface test as described above of them is a more description... Video below to hear the difference between a real vs. fake the ring test & visual test be. Another fake Morgan silver Dollar discovery in a two-year period sort of oxidizing chemical like bleach like BEWARE. They may even appear quite attractive a A/U '' which is the most effective methods in detecting counterfeits potential! Piece of dark/black cloth, or a cloth handkerchief, over both should. On 1914 Chinese Empire silver coins minted as trade coins by various countries to facilitate trade China! More in the title or description you can pick one up pretty cheap on Amazon bought a barber half that! Are flooding the market from China, are not crafted with attention to the stature of the dollars. Cheaply priced bullion and great customer service nicely designed silver bullion coins struck Chinese. Fake Chinese coin factory '' on Pinterest and introduced to national gold stockpiles hooked on the U had tail. The magnification / … World coins: counterfeit China Chihli year 34 ( 1908 L.